What would you do with a complete memory of your entire life? Would you relive your first kiss? Figure out what triggered your recent migraine? Remember the name that goes with the familiar face in front of you?
In other words, wouldn’t it be great to have a backup of your brain?
Gordon Bell is a walking experiment doing just this. Bell has been tracking his life in delicious detail for the past 11 years. It started at Microsoft Research, where Bell started the MyLifeBits project. His goal was to digitally record as much of his life as possible. He wore a camera, recorded his phone calls, scanned photos and letters, documented all of his computer work, and tracked his biometrics. The job of Bell’s colleague Jim Gemmell was to build software to make all this tracking easier, searchable, and meaningful.
This September Bell and Gemmell released a book called Total Recall: How the E-Memory Revolution Will Change Everything. In it, they talk about the future implications of being able to remember everything about your life in extraordinary detail. Bell proposes that a “continuous digital diary or e-memory” that integrates digital recording devices, memory storage and search engines will fundamentally “change what it means to be human.” Their work includes research into memory, work, health, learning, and immortality. A side order of privacy is served up too, as the authors distinguish between “life loggers,” who keep their records to themselves, and “life bloggers,” who broadcast their data.
Of course, self-tracking is not a new idea. People have been recording their lives in analog format ever since they started drawing on cave walls. Benjamin Franklin used to keep a detailed checklist of the thirteen virtues he was striving to live by, including annotated explanations of where he was succeeding and where he still needed to improve.
Now, it can all be monitored digitally.
It probably won’t surprise the readers of this article that I track myself. But it might surprise you that I track 40 different things every day. On a typical day, my pain level is 2, my weight is 126 lbs, I did 1 hour of walking, my happiness is 9, and I slept 6 hours. Charts like the one below help me to be aware of my mood, activity level, and sleep, and how these things interrelate.
With a background in molecular genetics and bioinformatics, as well as a history of chronic pain, I started tracking to help myself. But I soon wanted to apply what I had learned to help others. Here are two of the projects I’m currently working on.

QUANTIFIED SELF
Imagine a show-and-tell for grownups. Fifty or so people get together every month in the San Francisco Bay Area and New York City. They show each other the data they’ve collected, the tools they’ve built, the ideas they have, or the self-tracking projects they’re working on. Feedback and questions pop up from the audience. All of it is reminiscent of the Homebrew Computer Club.
This amazing group, which calls itself The Quantified Self, was started in 2007 by Kevin Kelly and Gary Wolf of Wired Magazine. They noticed a trend in people seeking greater self-knowledge, and using numbers on this quest to understand themselves. (Hence the name.)
SOME OF THE PROJECTS THAT HAVE BEEN SHOWN-AND-TOLD AT QUANTIFIED SELF MEETUPS INCLUDE:
So whether it’s for art, memory, health, or data for data’s sake, people are tracking themselves and sharing their results. We do it because we love data or because we have specific things we want to optimize about ourselves. As Kevin Kelly wrote, “Unless something can be measured, it cannot be improved.” When Gordon Bell is asked what he has learned about himself through the MyLifeBits project, his reply is unexpectedly qualitative: “That’s been a really hard question to answer... I guess it’s the rich set of connections and people that I’ve been involved with.”
Bell’s comment reflects the challenges that come up over and over again at Quantified Self discussions — questions that tend to revolve around two topics: motivation and meaning. How do we stay motivated (and motivate others) to track ourselves, and how do we make sense and learn actionable lessons from all of this data? The search for solutions to these challenges offers ample opportunities for innovation. Imagine self-tracking games that reward people for recording their health with badges of recognition; passive monitoring devices that remove the need to actively track yourself; social pressure in the form of online group challenges; prizes awarded to algorithms that turn messy data into beautiful insight.
CURETOGETHER
One step on this path of innovation is self-tracking applied to health. An example of this is CureTogether, a patient data-sharing site I co-founded with Daniel Reda where people come to self-report symptoms, treatments, and triggers for over 300 conditions.
People are tracking their depression, cholesterol, migraines, and countless other measures. Using migraine as an example, patients visiting CureTogether can see community statistics and learn that the top reported symptoms are “Nagging pain in one side of the head” and “nausea;” the top reported treatments are “sleep” and “ibuprofen;” the top reported triggers are “stress” and “not enough sleep” and the top related conditions are anxiety and depression.
Instead of narrative websites that provide emotional support in the form of shared disease stories, the quantitative data at CureTogether enables decision support and hypothesis generation. People are getting ideas for new treatments that they ask their doctors about. They are seeing how common or rare their symptoms are, and learning what triggers might be affecting them. While each individual’s data is completely private, the aggregate data is open for researchers around the world to analyze and use to make discoveries for the greater good. Some interesting correlations are already starting to emerge, like a potential link between migraine and fibromyalgia.
SELF-TRACKING WILL CHANGE THE FUTURE OF HEALTH:
The Quantified Self and CureTogether are just the beginning. Here are some scenarios that point to a fundamental shift in healthcare coming in the near future.
Alexandra Carmichael is co-founder of CureTogether, blogger at The Quantified Self, advisor to Singularity University, and mentor to several startups. Find her on Twitter @accarmichael.
Gordon Bell Homepage
http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/gbell/
MyLifeBits project
http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/mylifebits/
Jim Gimmell
http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/people/jgemmell/
Franklin‘s 13 Virtues
http://www.sfheart.com/FranklinsVirtues.html
Homebrew Computer Club
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homebrew_Computer_Club
The Quantified Self
http://www.quantifiedself.com/
Tweetwhatyoueat
http://www.tweetwhatyoueat.com/
Alex Rossi‘s Tweetwhatyoueat Video
http://www.kk.org/quantifiedself/2008/11/alex-rossie-shows-tweet-what-you-eat.php
Ryan Grant Talk
http://www.kk.org/quantifiedself/2008/11/tivo-for-life.php
Attila Csordas
http://www.kk.org/quantifiedself/2009/09/sf-bay-qs-8.php
CureTogether
http://www.curetogether.com/
PatientsLikeMe
http://www.patientslikeme.com/
FitBit
http://www.fitbit.com/
DailyBurn
http://www.dailyburn.com/
Can Vancouver’s General Fusion Bring About an Energy Breakthrough?
Read and comment on blog posts from h+ editor RU Sirius and others.
I really like the idea of artificially grown meat.
It really appeals to me when I see the huge areas of former precious native forest...
I find it borderline infuriating that men would have such objection to hormonal birth control methods designed for them, when women have had to...
Arnie, vaccines that clear amyloid plaques actually make Alzheimer's worse. It turns out that the plaques are neutral warehouses, the damage is...
Considering exercise; Read the book "Body By Science" by Doug McGuff.
You can find short videos on youtube that sum up the chapters of this...
Comments
'The Final Cut', a movie with Robin Williams was the first time I considered this idea and I still see it as a waste of time and resources.
My life is important to me, that's it. Playing it back either as video or as a data stream on the internet or even for high school kids gathering data just puts my stuff out to be judged by someone else who doesn't care that its mine. That is already visible in the comments on this man's work.
Besides, I really don't care how many boxes of Poptarts you eat or what mood swings you get from it and don't really understand why you think you're so important that it should matter to me.
FYI - 27 more hair follicles died today.... see? No one cares....
If you can't see the value in being able to see patterns in the moods you have because of the foods you eat, I pity you.
If you can't see the value to the masses in being able to see patterns in the moods many people have because of the foods they eat on the whole, you don't understand the importance of caring for a larger social good.
More than that, though, I think it's sad that you're more concerned with yourself and putting others down than being supportive of an experiment that others are willing to do with or without your support.
Sure, they put the info out there and put themselves up for scrutiny. Sure they're gonna get comments. But what if they also happen to find out that everybody who eats, I dunno, S'mores Pop Tarts for breakfast for 2 years ends up with depression? That's the kind of stuff you can't do in a lab.
Why "boo" them? They're not forcing you to do anything, and you'll STILL benefit from any discoveries made by their bravery.
So, Gordon Bell's been doing this for 11 years and when asked why it was valuable he replied: "I guess it’s the rich set of connections and people that I’ve been involved with." Basically, he could have gotten the same benefit out of golfing.
That sounds like pretty strong evidence that we shouldn't focus on recording every aspect of our own lives, but should focus on participating in recording a single aspect with lots of other people. The example of cloud-sourced medical experiments is a good one. The strength of the process is in gathering data about a group so that a person can optimize their decisions, not gathering data about a single person.
Focusing on each individual making a simple measurement, and aggregating those measurements across populations, rather than an individual recording everything they do, will also avoid the obvious problem of privacy. It's absurd to think that a person will ever be allowed to record every moment of their lives because many of those moments belong to more than one person. The example of not recording in a locker room is a good one.
Also, what does someone who records their entire life do when they're reviewing the recording they made? Do they record themselves looking at the recording they made? That could create a weird sort of meta-existence. Maybe that will be the next stage of consciousness.
To add onto Jim's comment about DHA. This graph doesn't show the correlation between fish oil and the subject's cognitive ability. All it shows is if one keeps doing math problems, one will get better at it. The author neglected to control for the fact that people get better at doing things through reptition.
Not to mention the potential placebo effect.
In the question, what would I do with a complete memory of my entire life? I think it will be kind of fun - but I've selective. Specially, someone like me who had a terrible childhood. Of course, it would be great to relive the good times. This is a very good article that makes you think. Ironically reminds me of Viktor Frankl in Search for Meaning
"Ultimately, man should not ask what the meaning of his life is, but rather must recognize that it is he who is asked. In a word, each man is questioned by life; and he can only answer to life by answering for his own life; to life he can only respond by being responsible." - Viktor Frankl
I make my living showing off the culture and highlights of Nicaragua. I specialize in "Responsible Tourism"
1. Responsible consumption,
2. Sustainable Tourism &
3. Just salaries
for more go to:
http://PatriaLimpia.org – about keeping Nicaragua clean, healthy and about educating kids and adults the importance of respecting the environment. I founded Patria Limpia in 2007.
http://adventurestourspackages.com – is a concise web page where you can just look for fun at flashed pictures and learn more about Nicaragua the safest country in Central and South America. AKA "The heart of the Americas."
Lifelogging sounds very useful. Lifeblogging sounds very frightening.
Let's say I'm in a gym locker room, and a lifeblogger walks into the room. I don't want my naked ass all over the Internet, thanks.
Neat article I like it, though this wasn't the way I was going. I have dyslexia and spelling is horrible for me, but I excel at math, 3D construction, and number recall in reverse and such. Until recently I always just assumed math was strong for dyslexics, but now I know different from recent research on the net. I like the idea of generational records and genetic memory as they apply to us, this article gives me a few more self monitoring ideas. Personally I will stick to A.I. agent type monitoring, as I interrelate with so few people and have and will lead a solitary life, only connecting some times to thought groups with intelligent views, even when I disagree to points. I still like monitoring humanity and some times have minor interactions with them on thoughtful subjects that some times I can relate to in ways, just like with this social group or community. As to the fish oil and math, I have a question. Are you sure that he/she didn't just exorcise the brain for math and got better each day/week. I see a line that appears as a statistical average before and after the fish oil, and no bell curve or deviation after the fish oil. So in that regard did the fish oil do it or just training and exorcise of the brain do it? The quantified self or quantitative self diagnostics is a great approach to better health. I look forward to seeing more things like that soon. Oh well 2 for the kettle :)
It seems like the DHA didn't have any effect. The trend was already towards shorter times and the rate doesn't appear to change substantially after day 80.
Post new comment